Tuesday, May 25, 2010
A Louisiana Fisherman's Story
"I tried not to let my grandson, Scottie, see me crying. I didn’t think he would understand, that I was crying for his stolen future. None of this will be the same, for decades to come. The damage is going to be immense and I do not think our lives here in south Louisiana will ever be the same."
Here’s the link to his story.
With all the talk of BP, clean up technology, and how the Obama administration has or has not effectively mitigated the situation, the human impact has often been overlooked.
The human impact: another argument for keeping the BC coast oil free. Visit the Living Oceans Society website for more information about the moratorium on offshore oil and gas in B.C.
Wednesday, October 21, 2009
How ya doing, chum?
Warmish temperatures during the day, cool ones at night, and my pumpkins are actually turning orange, which is a rarity in Sointula! With fall in full swing, and looking towards winter, I thought I would make my first blog posting since returning from maternity leave about something that also points to this time of year on the coast….the chum salmon run.
Some of you may be rolling your eyes. Why talk about the dog salmon (named because of their large teeth at spawning time), when there are cataclysmic events happening on the Fraser with the sockeye this year? Even the Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO) website says our poor chum is “the least sought-after of the Pacific salmon species”. Well, I have to ask, least sought after by whom? By the commercial and recreation fishing sectors? By the consumer?
Chum salmon are the last of the species of Pacific salmon to return to our rivers to spawn. In the ocean, they can often be confused with sockeye because of their silver bright colour, but as they approach their natal streams, they differentiate themselves by their distinctive vertical streaks. They are historically extremely abundant and spawn in more than 880 streams and rivers along the BC coast. In my neck of the woods, chum are just now returning to the Nimpkish, Kokish, Cluxewe and Quatse Rivers.
Last month, the Globe and Mail reported that bears on the Central Coast are starving because of the lack of chum salmon. Last year this was happening in Knight Inlet because of the lack of pink salmon. Poor cousin or not, every species of salmon has a place in the ecological web on this coast. And every species of salmon is under threat, whether by infestation of sea lice, warming ocean temperatures, or just plain mismanagement.
Stock outlooks posted by DFO for the 2009 chum runs for Johnstone Strait and Mainland inlets are either low or near target. What floors me is that the difference between the definitions of what is “low” and what is “near target” is substantial. An area that is getting a near target assessment is defined as “stock is (or is forecast to be) within 25% of target and stable or increasing”. An area that is getting a low assessment is defined as “stock is (or is forecast to be) well below target or below target and declining”. It’s like the point at which the pendulum will swing from one side to the other. Is it increasing or decreasing? Are we going to focus less on “managing” a stock if its near target?
And what are the consequences if we are mistaken?
* In researching this blog posting, I looked up the predicted returns on chum this year. All well and good until I want to see it in a bit more detail by stream. I have to admit I am mystified at how anyone can even find this information, let alone interpret it.
http://www-ops2.pac.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/xnet/content/salmon/webdocs/SalmonStockOutlook2009.htm
http://squamish2010.ca/SHOREKEEPERS/
Monday, September 28, 2009
Part 4: Interviews from Sointula - LEK from BC's Central Coast
During my interview project with Living Oceans Society, every single person I interviewed mentioned the Mifflin Plan. The Mifflin Plan is the colloquial name for the Department of Fisheries and Oceans Pacific Salmon Revitalization Strategy that came into effect under then-minister, Fred Mifflin. The Mifflin Plan was a reaction to a decrease in fish stocks in the 1980’s and it attempted to conserve the stocks by reducing the size of the fishing fleet. The plan went about this in two ways: buying back fishing licenses to reduce the number of boats able to fish and sectioning up the coast into zones so one fishing license no longer allowed one to fish the whole coast. It has been said that in one year alone, the west coast lost more than 8,000 jobs from the salmon industry. In a community whose lifeblood was the salmon fishing industry, it is understandable why this was such a huge blow.
The following is an excerpt from an interview I conducted with Living Oceans own, Will Soltau about his recollections of the Sointula-hatched action against the Mifflin Plan in the mid ‘90’s.

Excerpt of Interview with Will Slotau (contributed with permission)
"It was April of ’96 [that] we decided that we had to do something. There was a bunch of us from [Sointula] that went up to [the Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO) office in] Port Hardy. The secretary came up, these two guys just jumped up on the counter, went inside, one of them opened the door and we all rushed into the main office and we said “We’re not leaving until we hear from the minister that he’s not going to implement the Mifflin Plan!” and they said “Okay, good luck.” DFO got on the phone to find out what they should do." "So we made promises [that we would not be violent or destructive] and DFO left that night from work and they brought in a couple of commissionaires to sort of babysit us all night. The rotation of our people that were in the office changed on a daily basis. After about a week DFO didn’t like this free flow of people in and out of the office, and they didn’t want to drag us out and create a scene like that so what they decided they’d do was they would lock the doors and the people that were in there that day could leave at any time but they would not be allowed back in. There were eight of us, I believe, and we spent another eighteen days in there. It got pretty tense after a while. We were sleeping on the floor people would bring us food and they were still marching outside, they had placards by that time. " "Because of us, the DFO office in Tofino, Nanaimo, and finally in Vancouver got occupied but we were the first ones that actually took action like that. They might have even occupied the Prince Rupert office, I can’t remember. There were people that came from Port Hardy and Port McNeil once we occupied the office but the plan was hatched by a bunch of Sointulians." "Glen Clark was premier of BC at the time and he was all for supporting the fishermen, he had gotten the union behind him and there was a big press conference down in Vancouver one day and there was a bunch of people that had come to the office to protest. It was getting pretty noisy outside and I kind of felt like things were coming to a head with this whole press conference and the way people were feeling. Those of us that had been inside had had enough after eighteen days. So I let a bunch of people that were outside in and some of the people that were inside went out and from there it just kind of dissolved. Everybody was cleared out that evening, the cops showed up but they just kind of escorted people outside and then DFO locked the doors and that was the end of that. Nothing really came of it, DFO didn’t change one bit. "
Kirie McMurchy is a Guest contributor to coastal voices blog. If you have Local Knowledge about the ocean or about living on the Central Coast of British Columbia - we want to hear from you! Contact us at info@livingoceans.org.
Monday, August 24, 2009
Empty ocean by 2048? Maybe not...
Even if you do not pay close attention to oceans issues, chances are good that you’ve heard some variation on the ‘scientists predict the collapse of global fisheries by 2048’ story. This theme has its roots in an article written back in 2006 for the prestigious academic journal, Science. In this article, fourteen scientists – led by Dr. Boris Worm of Dalhousie University in Halifax – presented evidence of a global trend towards widespread biodiversity loss and the resulting loss of marine ecosystem services (such as fisheries). In one sentence, towards the end of the paper, the authors identify 2048 as being the date (extraploated from trends that they identify in the paper) at which global fisheries may be collapsed.
It was only one little sentence, and it wasn't really even the main point of the paper. However, the impact of that little sentence was incredible. In fact, there's a good chance that this lone sentence has had more impact on public dialogue than any other single sentence written in any academic article over the past 10 years: the specter of seafood “disappearing” in 40 years brought fisheries and oceans issues to the forefront of the public’s consciousness, inspired at least one documentary, and lent credence to efforts to stop overfishing. However, at the same time that the popular media were picking up the ‘2048’ ball and running with it, the conclusion – and the science behind it- were being assailed by some scientists.
The unofficial leader of the scientific resistance to the paper was Dr. Ray Hilborn, a prominent fisheries scientist at the
To hear the popular press tell it, what followed seems like the academia version of a standard romantic comedy plot: during the interview, the two scientists came to realize that they had more in common than they had realized. They soon agreed to collaborate on a research project, which grew to include 19 other scientists. The result of this project is a paper published in the July 31 edition of Science. For this project, Worm, Hilborn, and the rest of the authors evaluated ten large ecosystems for trends in both fish stocks and ecosystem health. They report that while the majority of stocks that they surveyed still need to be rebuilt, there is evidence to suggest that such rebuilding is possible through the use of four key management practices:
- Catch shares;
- Selective fishing practices including gear modifications;
- Fisheries removals that are managed to stay under (rather than achieve) Maximum Sustainable Yield (MSY), and,
- Establishment of areas closed to some or all kinds of fishing.
So, this paper spells out the basic management measures required for ecologically sustainable fisheries. The question, then, is how to use these four management measures in a way that is sustainable for small-scale fishermen and coastal communities. What do you think? Are there ways that some or all of those four management measures can be used in a way that encourages healthy and sustainable coastal fishing communities? What are your ideas?
